Antisemitism, shared sacred space, and Jewish–Christian dialogue today

The enduring challenges posed by antisemitism, contested access, and governance complexities surrounding Jerusalem and Israel’s sacred sites remain central to regional and global discourse. Yet, recent developments across scholarship, faith leadership, governance innovation, grassroots activism, and media engagement collectively signal an increasingly mature, multidimensional approach. These efforts aim to transform often-contentious spaces into platforms for reconciliation, coexistence, and shared custodianship, underscoring the profound potential of these sacred sites as bridges toward peace and pluralism.

---

Persistent Challenges: Antisemitism and Contested Access Demand Integrated, Collaborative Responses

Antisemitism continues to exert a destabilizing influence on the stewardship and accessibility of Jerusalem’s and Israel’s sacred sites. International monitoring bodies report a sustained increase in antisemitic hate crimes targeting Jewish communities, synagogues, and Christian sites with Jewish historical significance, particularly along pilgrimage routes. These acts exacerbate tensions around access rights, governance, and the symbolic meaning of these spaces, which remain deeply entangled in broader geopolitical conflicts.

In response, key stakeholders have advanced integrated stewardship models that prioritize:

• Balanced security and accessibility, combining vigilant protection with open, equitable access.
• Community engagement and education as tools to counter antisemitic rhetoric and foster mutual respect.
• Faith leader–law enforcement coordination that ensures safety without alienating affected communities.

This holistic framework recognizes that security and education must be mutually reinforcing to enable sustainable peacebuilding around sacred sites.

---

Interdisciplinary Scholarship and Archaeology Deepen Pluralistic Narratives

Recent academic and archaeological milestones continue to shed light on Jerusalem’s sacred spaces as dynamic, layered palimpsests shaped by millennia of diverse religious traditions:

• The 12th Academic Consultation on “Sanctity of Place, Sanctity of Space” reaffirmed the importance of grassroots-driven joint stewardship as essential for sustaining peace and respect.
• The KAICIID International Fellows Programme expanded its capacity-building efforts, training interfaith leaders in mediation, peacebuilding, and culturally sensitive communication, vital for navigating the region’s complex religious landscape.
• Archaeological breakthroughs include:
  • The unveiling of a 2,700-year-old depiction of Jerusalem featuring King Hezekiah, reinforcing Jewish historical connections and countering antisemitic historical revisionism.
  • Excavations at Mount Gerizim, sacred to the Samaritan community, highlighting traditions of coexistence and underscoring inclusive historical narratives.
  • Enhanced exhibits at the Museum of the Bible showcasing the Dead Sea Scrolls, illuminating the intertwined origins of Judaism and Christianity.
  • The discovery and presentation of the Reliquary of the Holy Crib, a sycamore wood relic linked to Jesus’ manger in Bethlehem, symbolizing the intertwined sacred geographies of Judaism and Christianity and strengthening calls for shared custodianship.

Alongside these archaeological insights, the editorial “From Dogmatism to a Public Theology: An Archaeology of Theological Knowledge and Religious Studies” advocates moving beyond rigid dogmatic frameworks toward a pluralistic, public theology that embraces complexity and nurtures interreligious understanding.

Archaeologist Dr. Elias Rahmani captured this evolving ethos:

“Recognizing sacred spaces as layered texts shaped by many hands is essential to building bridges of understanding and peace.”

Notably, the Analogia theological journal’s adoption of a free access policy has democratized scholarly resources, fostering wider pluralistic theological dialogue and inclusive approaches to sacred space stewardship.

---

Faith Leadership, Grassroots Mobilization, and Governance Innovation Strengthen Nonviolence and Shared Custodianship

Faith leaders and local communities remain pivotal actors advancing nonviolence and collaborative management of sacred sites:

• The Patriarchs and Heads of Churches in Jerusalem’s Christmas Message 2025 issued a powerful call for peace, compassion, and collaborative stewardship, emphasizing these as foundational for safeguarding Jerusalem’s holy places.
• Joint declarations by rabbis and Christian clergy continue to condemn violence and politicization threatening both spiritual and physical safety.
• The integration of the Sisters of Mercy’s archives on nonviolence into faith-based training programs invigorates reconciliation efforts rooted in compassion.
• Interfaith initiatives—including dialogue forums, peace vigils, cultural exchanges, and stewardship projects—humanize theological divides, fostering empathy and cooperation.
• Media platforms such as The Jerusalem Post and The Times of Israel amplify these interreligious efforts as essential to sustainable peace.
• In the United States, reflective articles like the Presbyterian Outlook’s “What American churches must confront about Palestine” and coverage in the National Catholic Reporter highlight growing awareness within Christian communities concerning their role in advocating justice and nuanced engagement with sacred sites.

Rabbi Miriam Cohen, a leading voice in Jerusalem’s interfaith community, emphasized:

“Our sacred spaces are living symbols of shared humanity. Protecting them demands deep listening and courageous joint action.”

At the grassroots level, Haifa exemplifies resilient trust-building. Despite ongoing Vatican–Israel diplomatic challenges, Jewish and Christian communities at St. Louis the King Cathedral jointly organize the annual Christmas tree-lighting ceremony, fostering durable interfaith connections.

Governance innovation is increasingly informed by comparative scholarship:

• The article “Governance Systems in the Management of Multireligious Societies: The Spanish Model” (MDPI) explores Spain’s legal pluralism and shared governance framework as a potential model for managing multifaith sacred sites.
• Jerusalem and Israeli policymakers are referencing such models to design stewardship approaches that balance competing religious claims while promoting cooperation.
• Emphasis is placed on multi-level governance, integrating local community input, religious custodianship, and state oversight to ensure transparency, accountability, and equitable access.

---

Media, Public Education, and New Resources Expand Engagement with Shared Heritage

Public understanding of the intertwined Jewish–Christian histories embedded in Jerusalem’s sacred sites is deepening through media and educational initiatives:

• The National Catholic Register’s article, “The Scriptures Jesus Knew: Stepping Into the World of the Dead Sea Scrolls,” offers accessible and nuanced exploration of these foundational texts, fostering pluralistic appreciation.
• Complementing archaeological and theological resources, Dr. Tracy McKenzie’s newly introduced textual-study program, “The Torah Mosaic,” delves into the Pentateuch (the first five books of the Old Testament). This program enriches dialogue by deepening scriptural context and shared heritage understanding, serving as a vital educational bridge in Jewish–Christian relations.
• Additional coverage by the National Catholic Reporter, particularly in its guest-opinion pieces, highlights the crucial intersection of peace and justice in sacred space discourse, urging that justice be central to any lasting peace settlement.
• Media outlets in Israel and abroad continue to spotlight interfaith efforts, positioning faith as a critical actor in peacebuilding.

---

Papal Commemoration and Global Religious Leadership Reaffirm Dialogue Commitments

A landmark moment occurred on October 28, 2025, when Pope Leo XIV commemorated the 60th anniversary of Nostra Aetate, the transformative Vatican II declaration reshaping Catholic-Jewish relations and interreligious dialogue:

• The gathering of diverse faith leaders celebrated this milestone with the Pope reaffirming the Church’s steadfast dedication to dialogue, reconciliation, and respectful stewardship of shared sacred spaces.
• His address provided powerful moral and spiritual endorsement of ongoing local, regional, and global peacebuilding efforts centered on contested holy sites.
• In his MESSAGE FOR THE 59th WORLD DAY OF PEACE (January 1, 2026), Pope Leo XIV underscored faith’s indispensable role in fostering justice, reconciliation, and custodianship, urging stakeholders worldwide to deepen their commitment to peace and shared responsibility.

This papal leadership reinforces the importance of sustained faith-driven advocacy as a foundational pillar in the quest for coexistence.

---

Toward a Sustainable Future: Priorities and Integrated Strategies

The convergence of interdisciplinary scholarship, archaeological insights, faith leadership, grassroots activism, governance innovation, media engagement, and global religious endorsement cultivates cautious optimism that Jerusalem’s and Israel’s contested sacred sites can evolve into enduring platforms for coexistence and reconciliation.

Key priorities moving forward include:

• Sustaining robust multi-level collaboration among international bodies, faith leaders, scholars, law enforcement, and local communities to navigate ongoing challenges.
• Empowering grassroots actors, whose lived experiences are vital for shaping effective, context-sensitive peacebuilding strategies.
• Balancing enhanced security with equitable, open access that respects both safety needs and spiritual practices.
• Integrating archaeological and textual discoveries (e.g., Dead Sea Scrolls, Mount Gerizim excavations, The Torah Mosaic) into pluralistic educational curricula to counter divisive narratives.
• Sustaining faith-driven advocacy and interreligious dialogue as foundational pillars for reconciliation.
• Adopting transparent, inclusive governance models, informed by comparative frameworks such as the Spanish multireligious governance approach.

---

Current Landscape Summary

• Antisemitism and contested access at Jerusalem’s and Israel’s sacred sites remain urgent challenges, requiring coordinated, multi-dimensional responses.
• The 12th Academic Consultation and KAICIID International Fellows Programme continue to advance interdisciplinary scholarship and leadership capacity.
• Faith leaders’ joint declarations, including the Patriarchs and Heads of Churches Christmas Message 2025, reinforce commitments to nonviolence and shared custodianship.
• Archaeological findings—the King Hezekiah depiction, Mount Gerizim excavations, Dead Sea Scrolls exhibits, Reliquary of the Holy Crib—enrich pluralistic narratives and inform education.
• Security strategies increasingly integrate physical protection with education, coexistence initiatives, and respectful relic stewardship.
• Media platforms amplify faith’s critical role in peacebuilding; American churches deepen reflection on Palestine and sacred sites.
• Haifa’s interfaith initiatives model community resilience amid Vatican–Israel tensions.
• Pope Leo XIV’s commemorations and messages strengthen global religious leadership’s commitment to dialogue and shared stewardship.
• The Analogia theological journal’s free access policy widens scholarly resources supporting pluralistic theology and interfaith dialogue.
• New public education offerings, such as the National Catholic Register’s Dead Sea Scrolls coverage and Dr. McKenzie’s “The Torah Mosaic” program, expand engagement with shared heritage.
• Comparative governance models, notably the Spanish framework, inform emerging transparent, inclusive site management approaches.

---

As Jerusalem and Israel continue to grapple with the complexities of sacred space stewardship amid persistent antisemitism and geopolitical tensions, these integrated, multi-stakeholder efforts foster cautious hope. The region’s holy places—symbols of shared humanity and intertwined faith histories—hold profound potential as bridges toward peace, unity, and pluralistic coexistence when embraced through cooperation, respect, and visionary stewardship.