******SCOTUS oral args in Trump v. Barbara on birthright citizenship EO** [developing]** [developing]** [developing]
Key Questions
What is the Supreme Court case Trump v. Barbara about?
The case involves oral arguments on President Trump's executive order aiming to end birthright citizenship. It challenges whether the 14th Amendment grants citizenship to children of illegal immigrants or tourists.
What key points did Justice Sotomayor raise during arguments?
Sotomayor probed the retroactivity of precedents like Thind and Wong Kim Ark. The administration argued for a prospective-only application.
Which justices showed skepticism toward birthright citizenship for non-citizens?
Roberts, Barrett, Gorsuch, Alito, Jackson, and Kavanaugh expressed skepticism on 14th Amendment jurisdiction for illegal immigrants and tourists. Predictions lean against the administration 7-2 or 6-3, with Barrett as a potential swing.
Did President Trump attend the oral arguments?
Yes, Trump attended the arguments and used Truth Social to pressure for a 'common sense' ruling against birthright citizenship.
What risks did the ACLU highlight?
The ACLU warned of risks creating stateless individuals if birthright citizenship is ended.
When is the expected ruling in this case?
A ruling is anticipated in June.
What historical cases were referenced in the arguments?
Precedents like United States v. Thind and Wong Kim Ark were discussed regarding the scope of birthright citizenship under the 14th Amendment.
What is the predicted outcome based on oral arguments?
The Court appeared skeptical of Trump's position, with predictions of a 7-2 or 6-3 decision against ending birthright citizenship, potentially with Justice Barrett as the swing vote.
Oral args recap: Sotomayor probes retroactivity on Thind/Wong Kim Ark, admin prospective-only; Roberts/Barrett/Gorsuch/Alito/Jackson/Kavanaugh skepticism on 14A jurisdiction for illegals/tourists; Trump attends/Truth Social pressures 'common sense'; predict lean against (7-2/6-3, Barrett swing); ACLU stateless risks. Watch June ruling.