Realignment of India’s trade ties with the US, EU and Canada amid tariff shocks and de-risking

India–West Trade and Tariff Shifts

India’s trade realignment with the United States, the European Union (EU), and Canada continues to evolve amid significant shifts in US trade governance, domestic political dynamics, and deepening strategic partnerships. The US Supreme Court’s landmark invalidation of Section 232 tariffs has set a new precedent, shifting tariff authority away from unilateral executive action toward a more politicized and judicially scrutinized arena. This judicial development, alongside ongoing tariff risks, partisan pressures, and diplomatic breakthroughs, is reshaping India’s economic diplomacy in a complex global trade landscape.

US Supreme Court Ruling on Section 232 Tariffs: Reshaping Trade Governance

In a defining 6-3 decision, the US Supreme Court struck down the President’s unilateral authority to impose tariffs under Section 232 on national security grounds, ruling this overreach unconstitutional. This recalibration of tariff authority from the executive branch to Congress and the judiciary carries several implications for India:

Enhanced procedural transparency and predictability: The ruling curtails sudden executive tariff impositions that previously disrupted Indian exporters, requiring more formal Congressional involvement and judicial oversight.
Heightened politicization and volatility: With Congress assuming primary tariff-making authority, decisions will be influenced by partisan debates, lobbying efforts, and electoral cycles, adding a new layer of uncertainty.
Broader judicial scrutiny: The Court’s active role signals that future trade and regulatory measures will face intensified legal challenges, potentially delaying or reshaping policy implementation.

Trade experts note that while arbitrary executive tariffs are now curtailed, the pendulum swings toward Congressional politics, heralding a “new kind of uncertainty” for exporters reliant on stable US market access.

Persisting Tariff Risks Amid Legal and Political Complexities

Despite this judicial shift, India’s exposure to US trade barriers remains substantial due to ongoing tariffs under alternative statutes and sustained political pressures:

The 15% global tariff imposed under a 1974 trade statute continues to affect key Indian export sectors including textiles, pharmaceuticals, and IT services, with legal challenges to this tariff’s legitimacy still underway.
Former President Donald Trump and his allies remain vocal critics of the Supreme Court’s decision, branding it “disappointing” and pledging to pursue legislative or executive avenues to maintain “stronger trade defenses.”
US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer reaffirmed that the US remains committed to protecting domestic industries, indicating that protective trade measures will persist, albeit through different mechanisms.
These factors contribute to a dynamic and unpredictable trade environment, requiring India to engage comprehensively across multiple US political and institutional stakeholders.

Domestic US Political Dynamics: Partisan Battles and Protectionist Voices

The Supreme Court ruling and ensuing tariff debate have become focal points in US domestic politics, especially during the 2026 State of the Union cycle:

Trump’s condemnation of the ruling and call for “strong, protective tariffs” underscores the persistence of protectionist sentiment within significant segments of the Republican Party.
Partisan divisions in Congress will heavily influence tariff legislation, enforcement, and amendments, injecting ongoing uncertainty for international traders.
India must navigate this fragmented political terrain through nuanced diplomacy that engages both executive and legislative branches, as well as judicial actors.

Diplomatic Breakthrough: Resolution of the India-US Digital Services Tax Dispute

Amid tariff uncertainties, a notable diplomatic success has been the formal resolution of the India-US dispute over India’s Digital Services Tax (DST):

The US officially withdrew its objections after prolonged negotiations, removing a significant bilateral trade irritant.
This resolution provides regulatory certainty for India’s fast-growing digital services sector and enhances investor confidence.
By aligning its digital tax framework with EU and Canadian standards, India has further integrated its economy with Western norms.
The settlement also fosters deeper bilateral trust, paving the way for cooperation on emerging technologies, digital governance, and cybersecurity.

This diplomatic achievement highlights India’s ability to balance assertive trade defense with constructive engagement.

Strengthening Strategic Partnerships with the EU and Canada

In light of shifting US trade policies and global supply chain realignments, India has accelerated its cooperation with the EU and Canada, focusing on:

Pharmaceuticals, electronics, and critical minerals with the EU, supporting European strategic autonomy and India’s manufacturing modernization.
Digital trade governance, cybersecurity, data privacy, and misinformation prevention with Canada, aligning regulatory frameworks and enhancing digital resilience.
These collaborations promote supply-chain diversification and resilience, reducing overreliance on China and bolstering India’s role in transatlantic and Indo-Pacific trade networks.

Such partnerships enhance India’s stature as a reliable strategic partner amid intensifying geopolitical competition.

Multilateral Engagement: Championing WTO Reform and Trade Transparency

India, alongside Brazil and Canada, continues to lead efforts to revitalize the multilateral trade system by:

Advocating for mandatory transparency in tariffs and regulatory measures to reduce unpredictability and unilateral disruptions.
Pushing for accelerated and strengthened WTO dispute settlement mechanisms, responding to global calls for a more effective rules-based trade order.
Aligning with Brazil’s President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s view that the US Supreme Court ruling offers a “reset opportunity” to restore trade stability through enhanced cooperation.

These multilateral initiatives complement India’s bilateral and regional strategies, reinforcing its commitment to fair and predictable global commerce.

India’s Growing Role in Critical Minerals and Energy Security

India’s expanding capabilities in critical minerals production and processing have drawn strategic interest from the US, EU, and Canada:

These minerals are vital for technology, defense, and clean energy sectors, positioning India as a key node in allied supply chains.
India balances its strategic autonomy with deepening economic ties, leveraging its geopolitical importance amid the US-China rivalry.
This evolving role strengthens India’s influence in global critical resource realignment and energy security dialogues.

Media Coverage and Public Discourse

Recent explanatory and live coverage pieces, such as “Tariffs Overturned: What the Supreme Court Decision Means for U.S. Trade” and “SCOTUStoday for Wednesday, February 25: SCOTUS and the State of the Union,” have contextualized the Supreme Court decision within the broader US political and legal landscape. These analyses highlight the interplay between judicial rulings and the legislative-executive tug-of-war shaping trade policy, providing stakeholders with real-time insights into the evolving environment.

Current Outlook: Navigating a Complex and Fluid Trade Environment

India’s trade realignment with the US, EU, and Canada is unfolding in a landscape characterized by:

Reduced risk of abrupt executive tariff impositions but increased susceptibility to Congressional partisanship and judicial interventions.
Sustained tariff exposure through alternative laws and ongoing political contestation.
Diplomatic successes such as the DST dispute resolution that improve bilateral trust and regulatory certainty.
Deepened Western partnerships that diversify supply chains and harmonize regulatory standards.
Active leadership in WTO reform and multilateral trade governance to uphold a rules-based global order.
Heightened geopolitical leverage through India’s role in critical minerals and digital governance cooperation.

India’s ability to balance economic pragmatism, diplomatic finesse, and strategic autonomy will be crucial in steering its trade relationships toward sustainable growth and enhanced geopolitical resilience amid global uncertainties.

Conclusion

The US Supreme Court’s invalidation of Section 232 tariffs marks a watershed moment, transferring tariff authority from unilateral executive fiat to a more politicized and legally scrutinized Congressional domain. While this reduces one source of unpredictability, India’s exporters remain exposed to alternative tariffs and volatile political currents. Concurrently, the diplomatic resolution of the Digital Services Tax dispute and intensified engagements with the EU and Canada provide strategic ballast and diversification.

As the US grapples with internal political divisions, judicial activism, and evolving trade policy frameworks, India’s nuanced navigation of these multifaceted legal, diplomatic, and geopolitical currents will be pivotal in shaping the success of its trade realignment and economic diplomacy in the years ahead.

Sources (25)